If you liked this
Games like Super Cat Herding: Totally Awesome Edition
If you finished Super Cat Herding: Totally Awesome Edition, the closest matches are Mewgenics, Welcome to Elderfield, Caves of Qud, Cult of the Lamb: Woolhaven and The Jackbox Party Pack 11. All 36 share its adventure genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.
91
Mewgenics
90
Welcome to Elderfield
94
Caves of Qud
93
Cult of the Lamb: Woolhaven
87
The Jackbox Party Pack 11
85
Back to the Dawn
85
Dead In Antares
89
Cult of the Lamb
79
Asdivine Knot
85
World of Goo 2
91
Stardew Valley
80
Wall World 2
78
Dragon Spira
79
Biped 2
69
Reigns: The Witcher
81
Coral Island
80
Finding Frankie
86
Cult of the Lamb: Pilgrim Pack
79
SpreadCheat
90
Arcade Paradise VR
81
Terraria
64
Machine Mind
36
7 Days to Die
Necesse
90
Arcade Paradise
82
This War of Mine
85
Heading Out
76
Ancient Phantasma
84
The Banner Saga 2
81
Prison Architect
82
The Long Dark
Gamble With Your Friends
78
Slime Rancher
85
The Life and Suffering of Sir Brante
75
Bear & Breakfast
80