Games like Soft Serve

If you finished Soft Serve, the closest matches are The Grim Reaper Who Reaped My Heart, Meet'N'Fuck Kingdom, Taffy Tales, Good Girl Gone Bad and Aitsu ni Choukyou Sareru to Do-M na Watashi wa Kanjichau. All 8 share its visual novel genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.