If you liked this
Games like Return to Atlantis
If you finished Return to Atlantis, the closest matches are Finding Paradise, Tales of the Neon Sea, Down in Bermuda, The Mystery of Woolley Mountain and Monster Girl's Labyrinth. All 36 share its arcade genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.
93
Finding Paradise
60
Tales of the Neon Sea
Down in Bermuda
The Mystery of Woolley Mountain
Monster Girl's Labyrinth
A Buttload of Free Games
Terminal House
89
UFO 50
80
Strange Antiquities
87
Lovish
70
Peglin
95
The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth
70
Earth Must Die
79
Lil' Guardsman
83
To the Moon
70
Super Technos World: River City & Arcade Classics
75
Tales from Candleforth
73
Loretta
Polity
73
Super Bomberman R 2
84
Hypnospace Outlaw
78
Sunday Gold
79
Unavowed
72
Gamedec
87
Year Walk
78
Tails Noir
81
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Spirit of Justice
82
The Blackwell Epiphany
76
Detention
88
The House of Da Vinci
A Tower Full of Cats
71
Broken Sword 5: The Serpent's Curse
83
Sega Genesis Classics
75
Hiveswap: Act 1
65
Gemini Rue
93