If you liked this
Games like Old Time Baseball
If you finished Old Time Baseball, the closest matches are Forza Horizon 6, Cairn, Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3+4, Skate Story and NBA 2K26. All 36 share its simulator genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.
90
Forza Horizon 6
87
Cairn
85
Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3+4
82
Skate Story
87
NBA 2K26
77
EA Sports FC 26
88
Forza Motorsport
87
EA Sports College Football 26
82
F1 25
85
NASCAR 26
75
EA Sports FC 25
81
Madden NFL 26
78
Football Manager 26
80
Madden NFL 27
80
MLB The Show 26
79
NHL 27
77
EA Sports College Football 27
78
EA Sports UFC 6
79
WWE 2K26
86
EA Sports College Football 25
76
NBA 2K27
84
Football Manager 2024
90
MLB The Show 25
79
NBA 2K25
80
Ride 6
78
WWE 2K25
90
Out of the Park Baseball 26
79
JDM: Japanese Drift Master
79
WWE 2K24
72
NASCAR 25
86
Rooftops & Alleys: The Parkour Game
74
NHL 26
79
Biped 2
84
PGA Tour 2K25
88
F1 23
77