Games like Love My Pegasus

If you finished Love My Pegasus, the closest matches are Diabolik Lovers: Lost Eden, Ikemen Oukoku Joou to Shinjitsu no Kiss, Sanrio Danshi: Watashi, Koi Wo, Shirimashita, Kaseifu Koi wa Keiyaku Kara and Wanted: Romance Renegades. All 7 share its visual novel genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.