Games like Ayakashi: Romance Reborn

If you finished Ayakashi: Romance Reborn, the closest matches are Amnesia, Wajin Ibunroku: Asaki, Yumemishi, Kami Naru Kimi To, Diabolik Lovers: Vandead Carnival and Diabolik Lovers: Haunted Dark Bridal. All 7 share its visual novel genre and are ranked by how closely their themes and modes overlap.